Luxon says Willis stays as finance minister until a new government. Law professor says she must go on 4 December
Nicola Willis lost her seat at the election. Christopher Luxon says she remains finance minister anyway, under caretaker rules. On Sunday he said, in remarks reported by interest.co.nz: "Caretaker provisions mean that Nicola will carry on as finance minister until the new government is sworn in, as you understand and know."
Andrew Geddis, a law professor, gives her a much earlier exit date. He told Briefs.co that ministers who lost their seats "are entitled under our Constitution Act to remain in office until the official declaration of the election results". MPs are formally declared on 3 December. Geddis said the Constitution allows one more day after that for any minister who is not an MP to step down. On his reading, Willis's last day is 4 December.
Special vote results are due on 27 November, according to interest.co.nz. Luxon has said he will only start formal coalition talks once official results are declared, Briefs.co reported. If talks wait for the 3 December declaration, Luxon has one day before Geddis's 4 December cut-off. On that timeline, a new government will not be sworn in by 4 December.
If Geddis is right, Luxon has to give the finance portfolio to a sitting MP before any coalition deal exists. Luxon's Sunday remarks don't mention a 4 December deadline or say who would take over finance from that date.
Finance isn't the only portfolio affected. Briefs.co reported that Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith also lost his seat and, like Attorney-General Chris Bishop, who is trailing in Hutt South, is serving in a caretaker capacity. Briefs.co counts 19 portfolios between the three ministers, though Bishop's are at stake only if he loses Hutt South. "All of those warrants are going to have to be distributed to someone on December the fourth," Geddis said, "but they'll then have to go away and negotiate who exactly should hold them long term."









