press.nz

CulturePoliticsEconomics

Former RNZ director says she warned the board it needed ministers' approval for $5m overdraft

A tall white-and-green office tower with a sign reading Radio New Zealand House above its entrance, under a clear blue sky
Radio New Zealand House in Wellington User:Dabbelju (wikimedia, CC BY-SA 3.0)

Jane Wrightson, a former RNZ board member, says she told the board that ministers would have to sign off on the broadcaster's $5 million overdraft, and that the whole board knew it.

She made the claim in an email to media, reported by RNZ, which is covering its own board. She doesn't know why approval wasn't sought. "It should have been," she wrote.

RNZ reported that the facility allegedly breached the Crown Entities Act, under which ministers must sign off on an overdraft like this one.

The Spinoff identifies Wrightson as the former chair of RNZ's audit and risk committee and says she maintains she told the board ministerial approval was needed. It also says few of the issues behind the broadcaster's budget blowout were flagged by anyone, including that committee.

Wrightson's account doesn't match the one board chair Brent Impey gave on Checkpoint on Thursday. Impey said that after the board approved the overdraft, but before RNZ formally entered into it, a director asked chief financial officer Hilary Parker in writing whether ministerial approval was needed. "The assurance given at that time was that RNZ did not require approval from either the minister of finance or the shareholding ministers to establish the facility," Impey said.

Wrightson said her term was ending and she wasn't involved in any later correspondence.

Both accounts can be true: a board warned by one of its own directors can still take a CFO's assurance. If Wrightson is right, the question for the review is why the board took management's word over hers.

Impey said the matter would form part of what the independent review needs to consider. "As a result, I will not be commenting further on this matter," he said.

Associate Finance Minister Shane Jones said it was "not credible" for the RNZ board to have missed the financial blunders, RNZ reported. He called the independent review of the $12m budget blowout too little, too late.

RNZ told The Spinoff the review would establish why internal financial reporting didn't accurately reflect the broadcaster's position. It will also look at whether RNZ's "financial controls, escalation, assurance and governance arrangements" were good enough.

The Spinoff reports that chief executive Paul Thompson, who has said he takes responsibility for the blunders, left RNZ "on Monday, six weeks early". Parker, whom The Spinoff describes as one of the people involved in the errors, walked off the job in October. RNZ staff want any redundancies to start in management, The Spinoff reports.

None of the published accounts quote the board minutes, so the public record doesn't show what Wrightson was minuted as saying, or how the board responded.

Sources

  1. Former RNZ board member says she knew ministerial approval was needed for overdraft
  2. You first: RNZ staff want the redundancies to start in management
  3. RNZ Business index